A fascinating question came up within our community:
Why is so much of our identity in South Africa centred around skin colour? In other parts of Africa, tribal identity seems to be more important.
Some argue that systemic forces have pushed this focus on skin colour. But what’s really at the heart of this identity struggle? And why does it matter so much?
Understanding Identity in South Africa
In South Africa, race has always been a big part of how people identify themselves and others. This is largely because of the country’s history with apartheid.
During that time, society was structured in such a way that race wasn’t just a label. In fact, it determined where you could live, what jobs you could do, and who you could marry.
While apartheid officially ended in the 1990s, the remnants of those racial categories still affect how people see each other.
For many, skin colour is still a primary lens through which identity is defined. This can make it tough to step away from these deep-rooted divides, even in a more open, modern South Africa.
Some say the lasting effects of apartheid make it hard for people to shake this way of thinking, but it’s also become a kind of default setting when it comes to identity.
Tribal Identity in Other African Countries
Meanwhile, in other parts of Africa, the conversation is often centred around tribal identity rather than race. In countries like Kenya, Nigeria, and Ghana, for example, people might identify first and foremost by their tribe—be it Kikuyu, Yoruba, or Akan—rather than by the colour of their skin.
In these areas, tribal heritage holds more weight in defining someone’s background and sense of belonging.
Tribal identity comes with its own set of challenges. The attachment to one’s tribe can bring people together through shared language, culture, and traditions, but it can also create divisions and conflicts, especially when politics, land, or resources are involved.
Just like in South Africa, identity in these regions is deeply complex, but the focus tends to lean more towards heritage and ancestry than outward appearance.
What’s Driving These Differences?
So, what’s at the core of these differing identity markers? It likely comes down to a mix of history, politics, and the social systems put in place over time.
- Colonial Legacy: When colonial powers carved up Africa, they imposed borders and systems that didn’t align with traditional tribal or ethnic structures. This disrupted established ways of identifying, especially when colonialists classified people based on race. The effects of these divisions are still felt today, as many African nations are left with borders that cut across tribal lands, often forcing different groups into the same space.
- Apartheid’s Impact: In South Africa, the apartheid regime made race the defining factor of identity. This categorisation of people into racial groups created a clear, structured hierarchy, cementing race as the primary marker of identity. Even decades after the end of apartheid, South Africans still live with this legacy, and the focus on skin colour remains prevalent.
- Cultural Traditions: In other parts of Africa, where tribal structures weren’t as disrupted by colonialism or political systems, identity has continued to be tied more to tribe than to race. For people in these areas, tribal affiliation carries deep cultural significance that shapes their sense of self and place in the world.
Why Does This Matter?
At the heart of this question is a deeper issue: how do we define ourselves?
Identity, whether shaped by skin colour or tribe, is central to how we understand ourselves and interact with others. But the danger comes when these markers of identity become barriers, either by dividing us or by boxing us into categories that feel limiting.
It’s worth reflecting on how these systems and histories affect our lives today. Are we holding onto labels that don’t serve us? How do these divisions impact how we view one another?
This isn’t an easy topic, but it’s an important one. By understanding the roots of our identity markers—whether they’re based on race, tribe, or something else entirely—we can begin to have more meaningful conversations about who we are and how we can move beyond these divisions.
What do you think? Do you find that identity in South Africa is still too closely tied to skin colour, or is this changing? How do tribal identities shape those in other African nations?
Mental Matters is a resource and information platform. We do not provide medical advice, diagnosis, or treatment. While the information on our website is for general awareness and support, it should not replace professional advice. For any mental health concerns, please consult a qualified healthcare or mental health professional.
Aspire Fitness Physical therapist Cardiff
Spec-Savers Heritage Mall Audiology Port Alfred
